Garage Door Replacement & New Garage Door Installation

Installing a new garage door offers significant benefits, from enhancing home safety and energy efficiency to providing the highest return on investment for home improvement projects. This guide covers when to consider replacement, material and style options, installation methods, and cost factors.

By: Kelly Larson | Published: April 9, 2025

Find Garage Door Repair Services

Get a fast & free quote | Schedule your service today

Properly maintained garage doors provide benefits that are crucial to your home’s safety, energy efficiency and value. Installing a new garage door delivers an average 193% return on investment—higher than any other common repair or remodeling project. 

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll cover the signs that it’s time to get a new door, the materials and styles available, installation methods and the average replacement costs. When the time comes, Garage.com will be here to help you with your garage door replacement and installation needs.

When To Consider Garage Door Replacement

The average lifespan of a garage door is 15 to 30 years depending on its materials and how well it’s been maintained. By the end of its useful life, your garage door will have provided safety and security, energy efficiency, protection from the elements and curb appeal. But when exactly should you replace it?   

The answer depends on several factors. It might be time for an upgrade if your garage door…

  • Makes strange noises even after you’ve attempted basic repairs
  • Has visible damage like rust, dents or cracks that could compromise your home’s energy efficiency
  • Has faulty hardware or rusting components
  • Is not properly balanced
  • Is an eyesore that could be lowering your property value

Old doors with worn-out hardware and outdated safety features are dangerous to the people and pets in your home. If it’s even a question whether or not your door is safe, it’s time to replace it. Installing a new door provides peace of mind, boosts your home’s energy efficiency and increases its overall value.

Choosing Your New Replacement Garage Door

There’s no shortage of garage door materials and styles to choose from. One of the most important, though, is what it’s made of. Consider your area’s climate and insulation needs before choosing from:

Steel doors are durable, low-maintenance and inexpensive, making them a top pick for standard residential homes.

Aluminum is a lightweight, rust-resistant material, but it’s not as strong as steel and doesn’t contain as much natural insulation.

These high-end products are the most expensive options, but they provide excellent durability and can last 20 to 30 years with proper maintenance.
Wood Doors
Composite Doors

Fiberglass is resistant to moisture, humidity and extreme heat, making it a popular choice for homeowners in coastal locations. It’s got a long lifespan but is prone to fading in the sun.

Vinyl is a rust-resistant material, is low maintenance and available in many styles, but it has poor natural insulation, so you’ll need to add insulated panels or have a professional install more permanent insulation.

Other factors to consider when choosing a new garage door include how well it matches with your home’s colors and architecture, and any included smart or safety features.

Garage Door Installation Methods

When you hire a professional to install a garage door, the first step is scheduling an on-site consultation. The installer will assess the existing system and its dimensions and provide a parts and labor quote. Assuming you accept the quote, the installation steps will be similar to these:

  1. Removal and disposal of the old door and its hardware: If you’re taking on the project yourself, be prepared to haul away and recycle the old door.
  2. Preparation of the frame: If it’s not level or has warped over time, the installation team may need to make some adjustments.
  3. Track and hardware installation: The installation team will mount the vertical and horizontal tracks, along with any necessary hardware, to the garage door frame. This step requires exact measurements.
  4. Installation of springs, pulleys and cables: Both extension springs and torsion springs store immense amounts of pressure. Do not attempt to install springs without a professional or the proper training.
  5. Installing the panel sections: The pieces of the door itself are then secured to the tracks using specialized equipment.
  6. Attaching the new door to the opener. Whether you’re keeping your existing garage door opener or adding a new one, the installer will connect it to the new door. 

The installer will then test the new system and perform a safety check. Most reputable installation companies will offer a limited-time warranty on the labor. Check the manufacturer’s guide for details on your new garage door’s warranty.

DIY Considerations

New garage doors involve heavy door sections, springs that are under extreme force, specialized tools and precise measurements. Some electrical work is also necessary to connect the new door to the garage door opener. Hiring a professional is highly recommended to help reduce the risk of serious injury. 
If you do decide to go the DIY route, enlist the help of another person or two for the project and have these tools on hand:

  • Locking pliers
  • Screwdriver set
  • Adjustable wrenches
  • Hammer
  • Drill 
  • Impact Driver
  • Pry bar
  • Measuring tape
  • Two ladders
  • Safety glasses
  • Gloves

Garage Door Replacement Cost Factors

The final cost of your new garage door is determined by a number of factors. Its dimensions, material, style, insulation, hardware and labor costs all determine what you’ll pay. Steel doors, for example, run between $750 and $3,000 on average. Wood and wood composite doors typically start around $1,200 and can reach $6,000 or higher. 

The sky’s the limit in terms of door styles and optional upgrades you can add to your installation. Before choosing, assess your budget, separate your must-haves from your nice-to-haves and always keep in mind the outstanding ROI potential of installing a new garage door.

Frequently Asked Questions About Garage Door Replacement & Installation

You can keep your existing garage door opener as long as it’s compatible with the new door. It should have enough horsepower to repeatedly raise and lower the weight of the new door. Keep in mind that, depending on the manufacturer, you may void the door’s warranty by mixing and matching parts.

When a technician comes to your house for an initial consultation, they’ll first ask you for the scope of work you’re interested in. From there, they’ll take some measurements, assess the existing system and provide a parts and labor quote that you can choose to accept or reject after carefully considering it.

According to the 2024 Cost vs. Value Report published by Zonda—a data company that provides insights to home services professionals—the average return on investment for installing a new garage door is a staggering 194%. This is up from 103% in 2023 and yields the highest ROI of any common home improvement project.

Ongoing maintenance for your new garage door should include routine cleaning, lubricating moving parts, checking the seals for damage, tightening screws and bolts and cleaning the tracks. Check the manufacturer’s guide for its recommended maintenance schedule. 

garage repair service provider repairing a garage door track

Get Your Free Quote and Schedule Your Garage Repair Today

Find top-rated companies for fast garage repairs and service to make sure your garage door system lasts. Get free quotes from garage door companies in your area.

Call Now
Request Quote

Tips and Expert Advice for Your Garage

Stay informed with expert advice on garage door maintenance, garage door service, garage door replacement, and upgrades. Explore our blog for guides, troubleshooting tips, and more.

Amarr garage doors logo

Amarr Garage Doors

By Jared Macarin
Posted in
Ask just about anyone in the garage door industry about some of the best names in the business in terms of reliability and quality, and you’ll hear Amarr near the top of that list. It’s with good reason with more than 70 years of production under its belt and numerous patents to help manufacture some of the best doors on the market today in various styles and materials.

Garage Door Opener Remotes: Selection, Programming & Troubleshooting

By Kelly Larson
Posted in
Need help figuring out your garage door opener remote? We’ve got you covered! Everything from different remote types and how they work to troubleshooting common problems and knowing when it’s time for a new one. Whether it’s just a dead battery or you’re looking to level up with smart home integration, find everything you need to know about garage door opener remotes.
martin garage doors logo

Martin Garage Doors

By Sean Donnelly
Posted in
Martin Garage Doors offers an excellent blend of contemporary and classical styles with many glass configurations, colors and finishes. With nearly 90 years of experience and dealers located around the country, it’s a go-to for many homeowners and businesses alike. We have fully reviewed this long-standing provider’s offerings and style options. Learn more about this premium manufacturer and our garage experts’ maintenance recommendations below.
highilift garage door installation seen beside normal door from the inside of the garage

High Lift Garage Doors

By Sean Donnelly
Posted in
Elevate your garage space with high lift garage doors. Unlock hidden vertical storage, accommodate tall vehicles, and revamp your garage’s functionality. This guide dives deep into the benefits, applications, and installation details, ensuring you know everything to maximize your overhead space. Discover how a high lift system can add significant value and efficiency to your property.
Garage door tracks on shelves in warehouse

 Garage Door Tracks

By Sean Donnelly
Posted in
Unravel the intricacies of garage door tracks with our comprehensive guide. From standard to vertical lifts, discover the right tracks, installation tips, and maintenance secrets to ensure smooth operation and longevity.
Raynor Logo

Raynor Garage Doors

By Sean Donnelly
Posted in
Raynor Garage Doors are among the most recognizable in the industry. Customer reviews show that it’s one of the more affordable options. This, coupled with its many finishes and included insulation, make it a popular pick among homeowners. Dive into this leading manufacturer to help you learn more about its products and the benefits of professional installation through Raynor.
Homeowner pulling manual garage door release cord in order to operate garage door manually without power or automatic opener.

How to Open Your Garage Door Manually

By Sean Donnelly
Posted in
Power outages or mechanical failures don’t have to trap you. Follow simple steps to manually open your garage door: just find the emergency release cord, pull it to disengage, and then lift the door. For a full breakdown, including safety tips and reconnection instructions, dive into our comprehensive manual.
Wayne dalton garage doors logo

Wayne Dalton Garage Doors

By Jared Macarin
Posted in
Since its inception more than 70 years ago, Wayne Dalton garage doors have been recognized to be among the best in the industry. As word of its quality workmanship grew, so did its business. Now, this company offers customers a bevy of choices to find and design their dream garage door to match their home’s aesthetics while providing top-of-the-line functionality.
Homeowner opening garage with remote garage door opener form driveway

Best Garage Door Openers: Complete Buying Guide & Top Recommendations

By Kelly Larson
Posted in
Choosing the right garage door opener involves weighing multiple factors including drive type, horsepower, noise level, and smart home capabilities, with options ranging from budget-friendly chain drives to high-tech jackshaft systems. Find the best garage door opener whether you’re looking for enhanced security, quieter operation, or convenient features.
garage door service provider applying garage door lubrication to springs

How to Lubricate a Garage Door

By Sean Donnelly
Posted in
Want a garage door that opens without a racket? This guide walks you through lubricating all the moving parts so your door runs smooth and quiet. You’ll learn exactly what to lube, what not to lube, and how to do it right. Plus, we’ve got some simple tips to keep your door in top shape and save you from expensive fixes down the road.
rack of garage dor springs in warehouse

7 Signs Your Garage Door Springs Need To Be Repaired

By Jared Macarin
Posted in
Are your garage door springs acting up? Don’t let a small issue become a big problem! Learn to spot the 7 warning signs your springs are failing, including a door that won’t open or loud noises during operation. This guide provides essential tips to keep your garage door running smoothly and when to call the pros.
Beautiful two-story home with garage in a serene neighborhood, perfect for families.

Sectional Garage Doors

By Jared Macarin
Posted in
Unlock the secrets of sectional garage doors! Discover why they’re the top choice for homeowners, from space-saving design to endless customization. This guide covers everything from materials and insulation to installation and maintenance.
Man working on garage door chain and tracks to repair a loos chain and tighten tension

How To Repair a Loose or Sagging Garage Door Chain

By Kelly Larson
Posted in
Worried about that noisy, sagging garage door chain? Our guide makes DIY repair easy! Quickly tighten it by locating the adjustment nuts on the trolley, loosening them, adjusting the chain tension until it’s ½” above a T-rail or ¼” above a square rail, and then re-tightening the nuts. Get all the details and learn when it’s time to call in the pros.